Live fuller for longer
Facebook-f Youtube Users
Advertisement

Change Singapore’s Attitude Towards The Arts Or We’ll Keep Dumping Books

  • Legacy
  • 2 months ago
  • Neil Humphreys

Font Size:

A
A
A
Change Singapore's Attitude Towards The Arts Or We'll Keep Dumping Books
One of my many pet peeves is the occasional conversation with the achingly cool, tech-savvy hipster. Oh, he’s so hip (it’s nearly always a ‘he’.) He’s all about the Web3, large language models and anything else that sounds vaguely Huxleyan and non-human.
And he thinks I’m an idiot.
Of course he does. I still have a “DVD collection“. An actual “DVD collection“, with punctuated air quotes and italics to emphasise his horror, along with the kind of facial contortions that suggest I slept with his wife on their wedding anniversary.
The dialogue is often priceless.

"You have a DVD collection," he'll say. "What do you play them on?"
"A DVD player. That's how these things usually work."
"Is it next to your gramophone? Ha!"
"It is next to my vinyl record player, yes."
"And I’m guessing it's beside your VCR?"
"No, that’s in my living room."
"But why would anyone need a DVD collection in 2025?"

Change Singapore's Attitude Towards The Arts Or We'll Keep Dumping Books - DVDs collection
Advertisement
Well, I’m glad you asked, generic archetype. Where shall we start? How about Singapore has one of the smaller streaming libraries, compared to the rest of the world? How about I want to listen to a director’s commentary or a critic’s interpretation of a film’s influence? How about I want to watch a cinematic masterpiece more than once? Or how about I just want to reconnect with an artistic experience that had a profound impact upon my life, in a way that only the best art can?
Or, I could just scratch the DVD collection, literally – yes, I’m getting to Yale-NUS – and watch the next Fast and Furious movie, the one where Vin Diesel fights osteoporosis.
I mean, what do we need to keep art and literature for in Singapore? Books? DVDs? They just take up space on a tiny pragmatic island devoted to the Bentham’s principles of utilitarianism, right?
Change Singapore's Attitude Towards The Arts Or We'll Keep Dumping Books - Library Books
So when I read the latest artistic dumping story, that student associates working at the Yale-NUS College Library were ordered by staff to destroy more than 100 DVDs in April, including DVDs from The Criterion Collection, I understood the logic. There are licensing and copyright regulations to consider, when it comes to audio-visual materials, and we must take such considerations seriously. Literally. Always literally.
As a result, students were given carts of DVDs and asked to scratch them with a penknife. Artistic vandalism? No, this was literal utilitarianism at its finest. The Criterion Collection happens to be a company that lovingly restored important films, in all genres, from all over the world. Their releases are still bought in decent numbers. I have many on my shelf. But we move on. Efficiency endures. Follow the procedure. The process. What’s the big deal?
Change Singapore's Attitude Towards The Arts Or We'll Keep Dumping Books - Stack of books
Efficiency over artistry
Well, let’s pop over to the recent, wonderfully efficient Lady Gaga concerts. From the station to the stadium, the turnstiles to the toilets, the efficiency blew visitors away. Foreigners made videos about the efficiency and we beamed with pride. No one puts on a Lady Gaga concert like Singapore. The procedure was followed. The process was impeccable. And did I mention the efficiency?
But do you know who doesn’t really follow procedure or process?
Lady Gaga.
And I suspect she’s got an extensive DVD library and never spent her formative years taking a penknife to the artistic works of others. I’d also suggest that when she attended her first concert, she never said, “I will remember this night forever. The speed of the queue. Wow. It has changed my life. When I grow up, I’m going to be a queue organiser.”
Perhaps that’s who we are though. Terrific organisers. Efficient processors. We take great pride in our planning capabilities and rightly so. Other countries post videos of their globe-trotting artists. We post videos of fast-moving queues going to see globe-trotting artists.
Maybe the old Lee Kuan Yew line still holds for many people. Art is a luxury we cannot afford. Or a luxury that cannot make money. Or cannot pay the bills in these uncertain times. Fine. That’s a fair and rational approach to take. I get it. I’ve written 32 books and will be able to retire financially only when I’m dead.
But at least be honest about it, rather than feign shock over the “operational lapse” that led to hundreds of physical books being destroyed at NUS, or students being asked to scratch DVDs from the Criterion Collection with a penknife. (A penknife! I wouldn’t write that scene in a novel. The satire is too obvious.)
Change Singapore's Attitude Towards The Arts Or We'll Keep Dumping Books - DVDs with a penknife
Because maybe the “operational lapse” is cultural, one that led to the closure of almost every bookstore chain here; one that led to Singapore having some of the highest piracy rates in the world; one that led to the arts being considered a non-essential industry during Covid; one that led to books and DVDs being destroyed at Yale-NUS without someone, somewhere, wondering if this really was the right course of action. And one that often leads to a lack of appreciation for books, DVDs and any other analogue, artistic collection in 2025. I mean, we’ve got piracy and AI for most of that stuff, right?
We do indeed. We can dump the lot. Outsource the lot. Rely on westerners and East Asians for our music and movies. Rely on hackers for our sports content and rely on AI to steal our literary collections. We can do all of these things and achieve international acclaim for what we’re really good at in Singapore…
Organising queues at a Lady Gaga gig.
Maybe we could host our own in-house arts awards, with categories like Best Walk to the Gig. Best Flow of Escalator Traffic. Best Book Removals. Best ‘Cut’ on a DVD Soundtrack.
Why not?
Britain’s got the BAFTAs. America’s got the Grammys. Singapore could have the ‘Efficiencies’. They might not be the most artistic awards, but there’d never be any operational lapses.

Also read:

Silver Spotlight: Daniel Teo — The Renaissance Man
Legacy

Silver Spotlight: Daniel Teo — The Renaissance Man

Daniel Teo is a man of many interests. The property developer is probably more known for his role in supporting the arts, and his wife, ballerina Goh Soo Khim. In this Silver Spotlight interview, he talks about his other passions, which range from helping the aging population to breeding parrots.

August 15, 2023
Neil Humphreys

Neil Humphreys

Neil Humphreys is an award-winning writer and the best-selling author of 30 books in Singapore. He’s also a radio host, a podcaster, a public speaker and the proud owner of a head of silver hair.

Share This Article

Explore More
Humour
Tech
Best Value
Travel
Foodie
Health
Advertisement
Recommended
Upcoming Events
Must-Do - Museum of Ice Cream Celebrates SG60 with 60% OFF
  • Museum of Ice Cream Celebrates SG60 with 60% OFF
  • Fri, 1 Aug 2025 - Sun, 31 Aug 2025
  • Multiple Timeslots
  • Retail
Advertisement

About Us

We’re a community created by silvers for silvers, brought together by a sense of curiosity and desire to live the next phase of our lives with joy and purpose. Expect useful tips and uncommon wisdom to enjoy living fuller for longer.
More About Us

Follow Us

Facebook-f Youtube Whatsapp Envelope
Advertise with Us
Contact Us

Get the latest stories!

By clicking Subscribe, I consent to the Terms and Privacy Policy to receive emails about the latest in entertainment, travel, food, culture, active ageing and living fuller in retirement!